I’m prepping for an AskWoody story about RAID 1 setups on Windows 11. It had me popping open my half-dozen or so NVMe enclosures yesterday to see what I had at my disposal. Among my inventory, I found two identical NVMes (ideal for a RAID 1 test). I also found a Crucial T705 1TB PCIe x5 drive, which isn’t suited for any of my enclosures. It really needs Thunderbolt 5 or USB4 v2.0 to exceed the 40 Gbps speed limit that TB4/USB4 imposes. Imagine my surprise when Copilot said no such enclosures were available, while Amazon showed me at least half-a-dozen products for sale right now. Hence my claim that Copilot, Amazon differ on TB5 NVMe availability.
If Copilot Amazon Differ on TB5 NVMe Availability, Try Evidence
I work with Copilot near daily, especially on understanding and fixing Windows problems, issues and misconfigurations. Warnings about AI hallucinations are always worth remembering with Copilot. Why? Because it has repeatedly shown itself to be wrong or — as in this case — misinformed. I reproduce Copilot’s response to my correction in which I provide the simple Amazon search that showed me 6-plus TB5 capable NVMe enclosures for sale at US$190 and up.
One big problem I see with AI information is that it includes no shades of grey. If Copilot and other AI interfaces could include confidence levels or probability of correctness, that might help. But no: Copilot, Google AI, Grok and so forth put forward their information as gospel truth. There’s a huge gap between Copilot’s initial flat statement that no TB5 NVMe enclosures are available, and its later correction to “TB5 NVMe enclosures exist, but most are early‑generation products whose real‑world performance is currently limited by host support and certification status.” Big difference!
As Always, Proceed with AI Cautiously
I don’t use or act on AI provided info unless and until I can confirm it through at least one (preferably, two or more) reliable public sources. This little “No it’s not; Well, yes it is…kinda/sorta” encounter demonstrates pretty well why that’s so. Indeed, for testing purposes I plan to buy one of the very enclosures Copilot told me yesterday didn’t exist. Today, it’s a different story!
Isn’t that just the way things go here in Windows-World sometimes? But at least, I’m going to be able to see if TB5/PCIe x5 Gen5 technology lives up to its billing when the Acasis enclosure shows up. If things work as reported, I’ll have an external USB drive that’s as fast as the internal drive on my production desktop.
